![]() |
||||||||||
Under the Agridome
Philip Shaw 11/20 10:29 AM
This week we saw markets drift a little bit lower again, something we've grown very used to since September. Of course, we are waiting for some very good news when that rights itself and we get all kinds of positive market factors to build demand and get grain moving aggressively again. In the meantime, many of us harken back to old arguments about diversifying markets and finding buyers for Canadian agricultural commodities. The problem is it isn't so easy. It has been a long time now, but I can give you examples where very high prices for corn, wheat and soybeans effectively killed demand before the prices of these commodities went much lower to build that demand back. Yes, we usually take the escalator up in prices and the elevator down. However, it never hurts to build demand where you can, and sometimes geopolitics is a part of that equation. Earlier in November, Prime Minister Mark Carney was in China to take part in the APEC meeting with other leaders surrounding the Pacific. It was there that he signed a new $400 million deal with China to lift agricultural tariffs. There was a 25% tariff on $116 million worth of Canadian pork products; there was also a lifting of a tariff and $285 million of seafood exports. There was also a reduction in tariffs on canola seed, and canola oil, peas, chickpeas, lentils and faba beans. It cannot be construed as anything other than good news. However, keep in mind the frosty relationship that Canada and China have had over the last few years. Who can forget the "two Michaels" or Huawei's Chief Financial Officer being picked up at the Vancouver International Airport. China responded to many of these problems by making them worse from a Canadian perspective. Our agricultural exports to China are always the lowest-hanging fruit, and tariffs applied to them were always the weapon of choice. So, seeing Carney last week shaking hands with President Xi probably meant a few different things to different people. It's hard to imagine China in Canada sitting around the campfire singing "kumbaya". However, we must remember China has a voracious appetite for agricultural commodities. They would consume the total production of Canadian soybeans in about 9 or 10 days. It's also pretty obvious that they will sell out Canadians if something cheaper comes along. That is the prerogative of the big nations versus the little nations. It's just the way it is. Interestingly enough, here in North America we have a convoluted view of China. For instance, it is no secret that historically there has been an adversarial view of China as a communist nation. Take a look at our news coverage, and you can always find trust issues when it comes to China. We have a similar type of trust issue with the United States now, but it's different than China. Let's just say we have a long history and there will always be some distrust between the West and East. This brings me back to Asia itself. I have often told readers that if I could have my druthers, I would sponsor a trip to Asia so you could see all of the people and how that is manifested in food demand. Our agricultural marketing organizations recognize that, and they're continually sending delegations into Asia to build demand for our products. However, I would just want the people on my proposed trip to realize one thing, and that is from the other side of the world, China looks different than it does from here. That look is much more positive than we have in Western countries. Simply put, it is a matter of perspective. As many of you know, I traveled to Bangladesh often, and when I am there, I am constantly passed by cars and trucks of Chinese citizens buying and selling within the economy. Bangladesh is sandwiched between China and India to some extent, two of the world's biggest economies, and it has been very beneficial to them. So, if you ask the ordinary Bangladeshi on the street about China, they typically will have a much more positive view than asking the same questions of the ordinary American or Canadian back here in North America. You might say that's just the way the world works and tell me to get over it. I get that, but I'd like to see them a bit differently. Differently in a way where Mark Carney signing a trade deal to lessen tariffs on agricultural commodities wouldn't be such a big deal. However, in the world we live in, it's obviously part of the road ahead. With our American friends somewhat openly hostile to a trade deal, Mark Carney has said that we are busy elsewhere. Thankfully, at least some Canadian agricultural commodities might benefit from that. In the meantime, we need to build more value-added opportunities for our Canadian agricultural products at home. However, we grow so much that we do need robust export markets that takes special negotiation like it does with China. Unfortunately, in these times it's almost the same with the United States. The challenge ahead is to keep those doors open, even when the political winds are the wrong way. We cannot afford to let ideology get in the way of selling what we grow. In the end, more markets mean more options, and in the commodity business, options are never a bad thing. Philip Shaw can be reached at philip@philipshaw.ca Follow him on social platform X @Agridome (c) Copyright 2026 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved. | ||||||||||
| Copyright DTN. All rights reserved. Disclaimer. |